I have recently made a decision. I am officially a 1911 guy. Before I was on the fence. I like my XD-9 mostly because the ammo is cheap and it will eat anything. Also it was my first real handgun. I kept telling myself that 1911s were nice but I will take the training classes with my XD because it will be cheaper and the gun is more reliable.
After much thought I have abandoned that logic. Here is why: First, I enjoy shooting 1911s. In my opinion no other gun can match a good 1911 trigger. Second, anywhere you can find 9mm you can find 45 and its not that much more expensive. Third, my every day carry is a sig p238 which is a 1911 style battery of arms. Fourth, I am a more confident shooter with a 1911. I know its all in my head but I just don’t feel as accurate with the XD. Fifth, 1911s give me warm fuzzys. Sixth, 1911 parts are available anywhere. 1911 parts (in my experience) are second most common to glock parts.
Now that leaves the outstanding issue of reliability. I have two 1911s. A Kimber and a Sig. I have read horror stories about Kimbers, but mine is rock solid. It eats anything. JHPs are not a problem. The only thing it ever choked on was incorrectly sized wadcutters cast from tire weights. Thats right pure lead, hand cast wadcutters. It has eaten everything I throw in it without complaint. So my 1911 experience has been great. I recently purchased the Sig with the intention of making it my go-to gun. I plan on using it for training ect.
Why Sig…{angry 1911 purist comment here}…? Well it had everything I was looking for at a reasonable price. I got the Tactical Operator, which has night sights, a mag well funnel, ambi safety, 4 mags (which is more of a perk really), rail, stippeling everywhere and it has got some great reviews. The best part was the price it was about $200 under a grand. Sure its a little hard to find holsters for (due to its slide geometry), but they are out there.
anyway /pontification. Have a good night.